1What the document states

The decision concerns a limited company, C, whose director, Mr J, was buying a rental property in October 2022. The purchase contract was in his own name and he planned to receive the rental income personally. He received an email apparently from his conveyancing solicitor, whom he had used for over ten years, asking for payment to different account details. Hackers had accessed the solicitor’s email system and changed the details. He noticed the payee name seemed related to a garment company, tried to telephone the solicitor, got no answer and assumed a partner might have a clothing business.1

He paid part of the funds from his personal account and part from C’s business account, both to the details in the fraudulent email. The genuine solicitor had not received either payment. The bank tried to recover the funds, and some months later the beneficiary bank recovered part of the money. The remaining loss exceeded £50,000. The bank declined to refund the payment from C’s account, saying C had authorised it.1

The Ombudsman did not uphold the complaint. The decision finds that a payment from C’s account does not make the loss C’s, that the intended purpose matters, and that the contemporaneous documents, including the contract in Mr J’s name, point to a purchase for his own benefit. The loss therefore fell on Mr J and not on C. As C suffered no loss, the Contingent Reimbursement Model Code was found not to apply, and the reimbursement rules then in preparation were not in force and applied only to later payments.1

2Elements recorded

Element As stated in the document Where in the document
Complainant A limited company, C, through its director Heading
Respondent Bank of Scotland PLC Heading
Date of the payments October 2022 Background facts
Provisional decision 18 December 2023 Provisional decision
Payee name Seemed related to a garment company, the director assumed a clothing venture Background facts
Same bank Stated by C, recorded as C’s argument with no finding Background facts
Remaining loss More than £50,000, the amount from C’s account not stated Background facts
Finding on the loss Not C’s, the property was to be bought in Mr J’s name Final reasoning
Finding on the Code Not applicable because C suffered no loss Rules and standards
Solicitor The Ombudsman cannot consider a complaint about the solicitor Final reasoning
Response deadline 22 March 2024 Outcome

The decision does not make findings on Confirmation of Payee, on whether the bank should have intervened, or on contributory negligence. It records C’s argument that the bank should have intervened, and it does not rule on it.1

4Check

The case turns on which account paid and whose purchase it was, so the check below is written for the payer who pays from a business account.

  1. Pay a purchase from the account of the person or company that is buying. The decision looked at whose loss it was.
  2. If the payee name on the screen does not look like your solicitor’s firm, stop. The decision records a name that seemed related to a garment company.
  3. When the solicitor does not answer, do not proceed on the new details. Wait and reach the firm on a number you held before.
  4. Report a mistaken payment to your bank at once, whichever account paid.
  5. Ask the solicitor’s firm separately about its own handling, since the Ombudsman cannot consider a complaint about the solicitor.

The page Before you pay sets out the general checks.

5Notes

Date.

The decision text carries no decision date. The date in this entry is the response deadline.

Same bank.

The point that the false account was held with the same bank is recorded as C’s submission only.

Scope.

The decision rests on the ownership of the loss. It makes no finding on the checks the bank carried out.

Outcomes.

This entry records one decision. It does not state how other complaints were decided.

Disclosure. Safe Payee is published and funded by Bulbea, which is named in this entry.
Sources
  1. Financial Ombudsman Service, Final decision DRN-4641430, ombudsman decision, DRN-4641430, 22 March 2024. Read 16 November 2026.