1What the document states

Ms Hawarden bought a property for R6 million on 23 May 2019. The estate agent had warned her about cybercrime and told her to verify its banking details by telephone, which she did. Edward Nathan Sonnenberg Inc, the conveyancers, handled the transfer. Between 20 and 29 August 2019 a cybercriminal accessed her email account and intercepted and altered messages, giving fraudulent banking details for the firm and removing fraud warnings. She chose an electronic transfer over a bank guarantee and, at her bank with the help of an employee, paid about R5.5 million into the fraudster’s account. She did not verify the details with the firm by telephone. The funds could not be recovered.1

The High Court had held the firm liable. The Supreme Court of Appeal considered only the wrongfulness of an omission causing pure economic loss. It held that such loss is not prima facie wrongful and that a negligent omission needs a legal duty grounded in public and legal policy. Ms Hawarden was not a client of the firm, no attorney-client relationship existed when the loss occurred, and the loss flowed from the compromise of her own email account and not from any conduct of the firm.1

The court held that liability would be difficult to limit and that the High Court’s approach would create liability for indeterminate losses, reaching all creditors who send banking details to debtors by email. It found she could reasonably have protected herself: she had been warned, and could have verified the details through contacts at the firm or with the help of the bank employee. Having chosen the transfer, she was responsible for failing to guard against a known risk. The appeal was upheld with costs and her claim dismissed.1

2Elements recorded

Element As stated in the document Where in the document
Court and date Supreme Court of Appeal, deemed handed down 10 June 2024 Heading
Bench Ponnan, Dambuza and Goosen JJA and Tlaletsi and Dawood AJJA, judgment by Dawood AJA Heading
Price of the property R6 million Paragraph 2
Amount paid to the fraudster About R5.5 million Paragraph 6
Period of the intrusion 20 to 29 August 2019 Paragraphs 4 and 5
Issue considered Wrongfulness of an omission causing pure economic loss Paragraph 16
Client relationship None when the loss occurred Paragraph 20
Self-protection Warned by the agent, could verify by telephone Paragraphs 20 and 25
Policy Liability would reach all creditors who send banking details by email Paragraph 21
Order Appeal upheld with costs, claim dismissed Paragraphs 1 and 27

The judgment is marked not reportable. The court also considered that a warning from the firm would have been ineffective, because the intruder was already in her account.1

4Check

The case turns on a buyer who had been warned and did not verify, so the check below is written for the conveyancer and for the buyer.

  1. A buyer verifies the firm’s banking details by telephone, on a number found independently, before paying. The court gave weight to the ways she could have done so.
  2. A firm tells each buyer in writing, at the start, that its bank details will not change by email and how they will be confirmed.
  3. A buyer who has been warned by the agent treats the warning as applying to the firm’s details as well.
  4. When a transfer is made at a bank, the buyer asks the bank employee to help confirm the details before sending.
  5. If a payment goes wrong, tell the bank and the firm the same day and ask for recovery.

The page Before you pay sets out the general checks.

5Notes

Law.

The judgment applies South African delict law to a claim by a non-client. It does not decide the position of a firm toward its own client.

Later steps.

Reports state that the buyer applied to the Constitutional Court for leave to appeal on 1 July 2024. This entry has not checked the outcome.

Reading.

This entry rests on the judgment as published on the SAFLII database and on the court’s media summary.

Outcomes.

This entry records one judgment. It does not state how other courts have decided similar claims.

Disclosure. Safe Payee is published and funded by Bulbea, which is named in this entry.
Sources
  1. Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa, Edward Nathan Sonnenberg Inc v Hawarden, judgment, [2024] ZASCA 90, 10 June 2024. Read 16 November 2026.