1What the document states

The Supreme Court gave judgment on 12 July 2023 on an appeal by Barclays Bank UK PLC from the Court of Appeal. The question was whether a bank owed its customer a contractual or common law duty not to execute her payment instruction where it had reasonable grounds to believe that she was being defrauded. The High Court had given summary judgment for the bank, and the Court of Appeal had reversed that decision. 1

The judgment records that the customer and her husband were deceived by fraudsters posing as regulators and police into believing that their savings had to be moved to “safe accounts”. She instructed the bank in branch to make international payments to accounts in the United Arab Emirates, and the bank telephoned her to confirm each instruction. She confirmed. Two payments, of £400,000 and £300,000, were made, and a third, of £250,000, was blocked. 1

The court held that the Court of Appeal was wrong. A bank’s duty to execute a customer’s authorised instruction is strict, and the line of reasoning known as the Quincecare duty does not extend to a case in which the customer herself has authorised the payment. The court explained the earlier Quincecare cases as concerning agents who lack authority because they act dishonestly against the customer, and not customers who are themselves deceived. 1

The court also considered the bank’s terms of business, which warn that authorised payments are assumed to be wanted and that money paid to a scammer is unlikely to be refunded, and which allow the bank to decline an instruction it reasonably believes to be connected with fraud. It held that this gave the bank a right and not a duty. It allowed the appeal and restored summary judgment for the bank on the claim that a duty not to execute existed, but refused summary judgment on the alternative claim that the bank failed to try to recover the money after the fraud was reported on 27 March 2018. 1

2Elements recorded

Element As stated in the judgment What the judgment decided or left open
Instruction Given by the customer personally, in branch, for international payments Confirmed by telephone before each payment
Bank’s knowledge Nothing the bank knew before 16 March 2018 was unknown to the customer The bank had no reason to doubt that she wanted the payments made
Duty claimed A duty not to execute an instruction where fraud was reasonably suspected Held not to arise where the customer authorised the payment
Bank’s terms Authorised payments assumed to be wanted; right to decline an instruction connected with fraud A right to refuse, not a duty
Recovery A claim that the bank should have tried to recall the money Left for trial for the period after 27 March 2018
Remedy A right to set the transaction aside and claim from the fraudster No claim against the bank for executing the instruction

Each row turns on the same point: who authorised the instruction, and what the bank knew that the customer did not. The judgment treats a payment the customer gave personally as valid even where she was deceived into giving it.

4Check

The judgment gives no advice to payers. Its account of the facts shows the point at which a reader can act: the instruction was the customer’s own, so the check has to come before it is given.

  1. Treat any request to move money to a “safe” account, from a person who says they are a regulator, a police officer or your bank, as a reason to stop. End the call and contact the organisation on a number you find yourself, from its published sources or from your card.
  2. Before you confirm a payment to your bank, ask yourself whether you started the request. A confirmation you give by telephone records that you authorised the payment.
  3. Do not rely on your bank to decline an instruction you have given. The judgment holds that the bank’s duty is to carry it out, and that a right to refuse is not a duty.
  4. If you have paid, tell your bank at once, in writing, and ask it to try to recover the money. The claim left for trial concerned the period after the fraud was reported. The steps for the first hours are on After a fraud.

5Notes

Facts.

The judgment concerns international payments from a personal account. This entry records no finding about payments between businesses.

Stage.

The court decided a question of law on an application for summary judgment. It did not hold a trial, and the alternative claim on recovery was not decided on its merits.

Later rules.

The judgment refers to a reimbursement code and to a new mandatory reimbursement scheme. This entry does not record how either would apply to the same facts.

Parties.

The parties are recorded as the case title gives them, and nothing is stated about them beyond the judgment.

Disclosure. Safe Payee is published and funded by Bulbea, which is named in this entry.
Sources
  1. Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, Philipp v Barclays Bank UK PLC, judgment, [2023] UKSC 25, 12 July 2023. Read 16 November 2026.