1What the document states
The decision concerns a buyer who had corresponded with his conveyancing solicitor by email since November 2020. Contracts were exchanged on 9 March 2021 and he paid the 10% deposit by online banking. On 11 March the solicitor telephoned to say another client had received a scam email asking for a transfer. The buyer says the warning was general and gave no context. On 15 March he received an email that appeared to come from the solicitor, in the same chain as the earlier genuine messages, with an attached letter bearing the correct logo and address and giving account details different from those used for the deposit.1
He made two payments of £50,000 to the new details. The first was processed. The second was stopped, and the bank asked him to check the details with the solicitor. The solicitor said no request for the balance had been made. The bank contacted the receiving bank on the day, and no funds remained. The bank had already refunded half the loss, £25,000, and the dispute concerned the other half.1
The Ombudsman upheld the complaint. The bank relied on two exceptions in the Contingent Reimbursement Model Code, that the customer ignored an effective warning and that he lacked a reasonable basis for believing the payee was genuine. The decision finds the warning shown in the payment journey was relevant but did not bring the risk to life: it did not explain that a fraudulent email can appear to come from the genuine address, sit within a genuine chain, arrive when a payment is expected and look identical to genuine correspondence. On the second exception the decision finds he had a reasonable basis, since he had dealt with the solicitor for months and the email arrived at the expected stage.1
2Elements recorded
| Element | As stated in the document | Where in the document |
|---|---|---|
| Respondent | Barclays Bank UK PLC | Heading |
| Payments | Two payments of £50,000 to the new details on the same occasion | Background |
| First payment | Processed, flagged by the bank’s system, no call to the customer | Reasoning |
| Second payment | Stopped, customer asked to verify with the solicitor | Background |
| Refund before the decision | £25,000 | Outcome |
| Redress | Remaining £25,000 within 28 days of acceptance, with 8% simple interest from the payment date | Outcome |
| Warning | Found not impactful enough to meet the Code’s effective warning criteria | Reasoning |
| Reasonable basis | Found met | Reasoning |
| Employment point | The bank’s claim that the customer’s work in financial services should have given him insight was rejected | Reasoning |
| Acceptance deadline | 28 April 2022 | Outcome |
The decision states that both payments were flagged by the bank’s fraud detection system and that only the second led to a call. It finds that, had the bank spoken to the customer about the first payment, he would probably have verified the details with the solicitor as he did for the second, and the scam would probably have been uncovered before any funds left.1
4Check
The case concerns a balance paid after an email that sat inside a genuine chain, so the check below is written for the buyer who is about to pay.
- A request for the balance, or any change of account details, is verified by telephone on a number you held before the email, even when the email sits in a chain of genuine messages.
- Do not rely on the logo, the address on a letter or the earlier deposit to establish that the details are right.
- If your bank stops a payment and asks you to verify the details, do so with the solicitor before you try again.
- If a payment has gone to the wrong party, tell your bank at once and ask it to contact the receiving bank.
- Keep the email chain, the attached letter and any warning screen the bank showed you.
The page Before you pay sets out the general checks.
5Notes
The decision text carries no decision date. The date in this entry is the acceptance deadline.
The Code applied because the bank is a signatory. This entry does not state whether it applies to a given bank today.
The decision records two payments of £50,000, of which the first was processed. It describes the £25,000 already refunded as half the loss.
This entry records one decision. It does not state how other complaints were decided.
- Financial Ombudsman Service, Final decision DRN-3372966, ombudsman decision, DRN-3372966, 28 April 2022. Read 16 November 2026.