1What the document states

The Ombudsman for the Channel Islands records that on 18 September 2018 at 10:49 a customer emailed her bank in Guernsey to give advance notice of a payment of £434,000 to an investment fund. The bank does not accept payment instructions by email, so it did not treat the message as an instruction. At 11:37, forty-eight minutes later, she emailed again to say the transfer details had changed. The new details, attached as a note apparently from her investment adviser, named an account at a bank in the United Kingdom instead of the fund’s original account in Jersey.1

On 19 September she attended the branch to give the instruction in person and sign the authority, and a member of staff completed the payment using the updated details. The bank says no change of details was raised during that visit. Six days later she told the bank the money had not arrived, and the investment services company said her email account had probably been compromised and that it had not sent new details. The receiving bank returned £269,886.14 between November 2018 and February 2019, which left £164,113.86 unrecovered.1

The Ombudsman upheld the complaint. The decision records that email intercept fraud, including late changes to payment details, was known in the industry by 2018, and that the bank knew the risk of email instructions because it refused to accept them. It found the bank had two opportunities, on 18 and 19 September, to recommend that she verify the beneficiary details with the investment services company, and did not take either. The bank had argued that the customer should bear part of the loss on four grounds, and the Ombudsman rejected each of them.1

2Elements recorded

Element As stated in the document Where in the document
Decision date 12 October 2020 Heading
Respondent Lloyds Bank Corporate Markets plc, trading as Lloyds Bank International, Guernsey branch Heading
Amount instructed £434,000 Facts and timeline
Recovered £269,886.14 Facts and timeline
Not recovered £164,113.86 Facts and timeline
Redress Settlement of £150,000, plus a recommendation to pay £14,113.86 and 8% simple interest on £164,113.86 from 19 September 2018 Outcome
Limit of the office The Ombudsman can recommend, but not require, payment above £150,000 Outcome
Standards applied Local principles of conduct, code of practice for banks and regulator warnings of 2013 and 2015 on compromised email accounts Reasoning
Reference to UK practice Guernsey customers should generally receive broadly equivalent protection, without direct application of UK regulation Reasoning
Acceptance deadline 11 November 2020 Outcome

The four grounds of contribution that the bank put forward concerned the tone of the fraudsters’ covering email, a slightly different reply address, a warning in the footer of the adviser’s genuine emails, and the six days before the customer chased the payment. The decision answers each in turn: the attached form matched the earlier one, the address differed only slightly, the footer warning was the last of six paragraphs in smaller type, and the six days spanned a weekend.1

4Check

The case turns on a change of details that arrived by email shortly after an earlier message, so the check below is written for the payer who has received new details.

  1. Treat any message that changes account details as unverified, however closely it matches earlier correspondence, and however soon after the first message it arrives.
  2. Telephone the recipient on a number you held before the change and confirm the new account, name and sort code or equivalent.
  3. When you give an instruction in branch, say that the details changed by email. The decision records that the bank had two chances to prompt a check and did not.
  4. If a payment has gone to the wrong party, tell your bank the same day and ask it to contact the receiving bank.
  5. Keep the emails, the attached forms and the record of the visit, as the case turned on what was said and when.

The page Before you pay sets out the general checks.

5Notes

Jurisdiction.

The decision applies Guernsey law and standards. It states that it does not directly apply United Kingdom regulation.

Redress.

The Ombudsman can recommend payment above £150,000 and cannot require it.

Parties.

The decision notes that the investment services company and the receiving bank are involved and that the complaint is against one bank only.

Evidence.

The two staff members involved had left the bank, and the decision records the bank’s account of the visit.

Outcomes.

This entry records one decision. It does not state how other complaints were decided.

Disclosure. Safe Payee is published and funded by Bulbea, which is named in this entry.
Sources
  1. Channel Islands Financial Ombudsman, Final Decision, reference 18-000424, ombudsman decision, 18-000424, 12 October 2020. Read 16 November 2026.